Private health insurance faces a difficult tension. The system needs strong participation to support Australia’s mixed public and private healthcare model, yet affordability pressures are prompting some consumers to downgrade, suspend or abandon their cover.
For younger Australians in particular, the value equation is becoming harder to explain. They may pay premiums for years without claiming, while much of the industry’s visible investment remains concentrated on acquiring and switching customers.
In this episode of Innovation Insider, I spoke with nib Managing Director and CEO Ed Close about the choices facing insurers and the future he wants nib to help create.
The conversation covered competition, prevention, partnerships, alternative care models, artificial intelligence and the role insurers could play in making healthcare easier to navigate.
Putting private health insurance first
Since becoming CEO in December 2024, Ed has sharpened nib’s focus around a “private health insurance first” strategy. That does not mean abandoning adjacent businesses or new opportunities. It means applying a clearer test to them: does this strengthen the core private health insurance proposition?
That discipline matters. Insurers are being presented with countless opportunities across healthcare delivery, technology, distribution and wellbeing. The challenge is deciding which investments create meaningful member value and which simply add complexity.
For nib, Ed sees brand, distribution, data and partnerships as important sources of advantage. The ambition is to use those strengths to make private health insurance more relevant across different generations and customer segments.
The cost of competing for the same customers
Competition is healthy when it creates better products, services and prices. It becomes less useful when enormous amounts of money are spent moving existing customers between insurers.
Ed estimates that the industry spends around $200 million each year on broker commissions and another $500 million on acquisition offers. Those numbers raise an uncomfortable question: how much value is being created for consumers, and how much is simply funding churn?
The current rules can also create a larger discount for someone joining a fund than for an existing member who has remained loyal. While these settings are designed to support competition, they may also encourage switching and increase the cost of acquisition across the sector.
That spending eventually needs to be recovered. In an environment where households are already questioning affordability, the industry must consider whether its competition settings are supporting sustainable participation.
Younger Australians need more immediate value
The challenge is particularly pronounced for younger people.
nib built much of its early growth around being a relevant and accessible brand for younger Australians. That segment remains important, but the economics of serving it have become more difficult.
Ed explained that, under nib’s analysis, between $800 and $900 of the first $1,000 contributed by a younger consumer on a basic policy can be absorbed through risk equalisation before that person makes a claim.
This makes it harder to create compelling value through lower-cost hospital products alone.
Insurers therefore need to deliver value that consumers can experience before they require hospital treatment. That could include prevention, health advice, care navigation, early intervention and easier access to appropriate services.
Without this shift, the industry risks asking younger people to keep paying for a proposition whose value may feel distant or invisible.

Download a free copy of our PHI Innovation Report
It’s Australia’s definitive benchmark of private health insurance innovation, ranking the nation’s leading funds and revealing the strategies reshaping affordability, prevention and digital care.
Exclusively free for Innovation Insiders

A bias towards partnerships
Some insurers are expanding their role through vertical integration, acquiring or building healthcare delivery capabilities. nib has taken a different approach, with what Ed describes as a “bias for partnerships”.
Its model includes partnerships with providers, distributors and other insurers. The Qantas relationship is one example, combining a trusted consumer brand and large customer base with nib’s insurance infrastructure.
Honeysuckle Health offers another model. It supports services such as chronic disease management, rehabilitation in the home and hospital substitution, while also making these capabilities available to other health funds. According to Ed, Honeysuckle Health turned a profit in the last financial year. Its programs are also producing strong customer advocacy, with Net Promoter Scores frequently reaching the 80s and 90s.
This is significant because it suggests alternative care models can create value on several fronts. They can improve the customer experience, support better health outcomes, help manage claims inflation and strengthen retention.
Partnerships also allow insurers to access capabilities and scale without needing to own every part of the healthcare journey.
Prevention still faces a structural handbrake
The logic for prevention appears straightforward. If insurers cannot refuse cover or price people according to their health risk, they should have a strong incentive to help members remain healthier.
The reality is more complicated. Ed identified two major barriers: risk equalisation and member switching.
Risk equalisation can redistribute some of the financial benefit created by an insurer’s prevention investment across the broader industry. Portability then creates the possibility that a member will switch funds before the original insurer receives the long-term benefit.
“If there is no incentive for health insurers to proactively manage that claims experience, that’s a big handbrake on investment in prevention.”
Prevention programs may take six, seven or even nine years to demonstrate their full financial return. That is a difficult investment case when membership can be lost much sooner and some of the benefit may be shared with competitors.
nib supports moving towards a prospective risk equalisation model, similar to approaches used overseas. Under such a model, insurers could be more directly recognised and rewarded for proactively managing the health risks within their membership.
Regulatory reform will be important, although insurers do not need to wait for a perfect system. Prevention can also create more immediate value through acquisition, engagement, advocacy and retention. Business cases that recognise these benefits may support investment even when the claims return takes longer to emerge.
AI is moving into practical application
The conversation also provided a useful example of artificial intelligence moving beyond experimentation. It’sMyGroup, in which nib holds a minority interest, has developed a “compliance as a service” capability for health insurance sales, retention and service calls.
Traditional quality assurance often relies on people manually reviewing a small sample of calls. The AI-enabled model can evaluate calls at scale and surface insights for leaders and consultants in near real time.
This creates the potential for faster coaching, better compliance, greater consistency and improved customer outcomes. The example matters because it is grounded in a specific operational problem. The value is measurable and the application can be extended across multiple insurers.
We are likely to see more progress from AI when it is applied in this way, solving clearly defined customer or operational problems rather than being treated as a strategy in itself.

Stop guessing where AI fits in PHI
Get a clear view of where to start, what matters, and what comes next.
10 practical use cases. Real implications for PHIs. Exclusively free for Innovation Insiders

Care navigation could become the real differentiator
When I asked Ed what he wanted the nib customer experience to look like in 10 years, his answer centred on connectivity and navigation.
Healthcare remains difficult for consumers to understand. People often struggle to know which service they need, where to find it, what it will cost and what their insurance will cover. Every disconnected handover creates frustration and allows value to leak from the system.
Insurers are well placed to help address this problem. They already hold relationships with members, providers and healthcare partners, along with data that can support more relevant guidance.
The opportunity is to help people move through healthcare more simply, connecting them with appropriate services earlier and making the value of their cover more visible.
If insurers can solve care navigation, they can improve the member experience while reducing avoidable cost and inefficiency. They can also begin shifting the proposition from paying claims after people become unwell towards helping members make better health decisions earlier.
The participation question
Private healthcare works best when consumers, providers, insurers and government can all see value in participating.
Hospitals need sustainable patient volumes. Consumers need affordable cover and confidence that it will support them when required. Insurers need sufficient participation to maintain a balanced membership base and invest in better services.
The sector’s long-term challenge is therefore bigger than winning market share. It is about strengthening the value of private healthcare itself.
That will require more disciplined competition, better incentives for prevention, scalable partnerships and a simpler experience for consumers. It will also require insurers to demonstrate value between claims, particularly for younger and healthier members.
Private health insurance is at an inflection point. The funds that succeed will be those that help people understand, access and navigate healthcare more effectively, while keeping participation sustainable for the system as a whole.
Watch or listen to the full episode of Innovation Insider with nib Managing Director and CEO Ed Close 👇🏻
Subscribe to Innovation Insider and never miss an episode 👇🏻


