Australians don’t fully understand their health insurance, many believe it’s expensive, and most think the system needs an overhaul. And yet, they’re still holding on.
That’s the headline from Australian Unity’s latest research. On the surface, it feels reassuring for insurers, a sign that despite the noise, the core value of private health insurance still holds. Look a little closer, though, and a different picture starts to emerge.
What the data is really telling us
The findings point to a system that is holding together, but under increasing strain. This is less about strong loyalty and more about a combination of habit, perceived necessity, and limited clarity on alternatives.
Confusion is being tolerated, not resolved
A large portion of Australians admit they don’t clearly understand their policy, yet they continue to pay their premiums. That behaviour has been relatively stable for years, largely because the perceived risk of not having cover has outweighed the frustration of navigating it.
As premiums rise and cost-of-living pressure builds, that tolerance starts to wear thin. Confusion shifts from something people live with to something they actively question, particularly when they are being forced to reassess household spending more frequently.
Value is now being weighed against everyday choices
One of the more telling insights is what people are willing to give up to keep their cover. Streaming services, gym memberships, and other discretionary expenses are being cut to make room for premiums.
That changes the role of private health insurance in a household budget. It moves from a background expense to something that is actively prioritised, often at the expense of other parts of daily life.
When that happens, value becomes much more immediate. Members are no longer passively paying, they are making an ongoing decision to continue.
Switching behaviour points to limited differentiation
More than half of Australians are considering switching providers, with cost being the primary driver. That level of switching intent highlights how similar most funds appear from a member’s perspective.
In a market where differences are not clearly felt or understood, price naturally becomes the dominant factor. Incremental improvements, whether in product design or communication, tend to have limited impact when the overall experience feels largely the same.
Trust in the system is under pressure
Nearly nine in ten Australians believe the health insurance system needs an overhaul. That sentiment reflects a broader concern about affordability, complexity, and whether the system is keeping pace with modern healthcare needs.
Trust tends to erode gradually. These kinds of signals suggest that expectations are shifting faster than the system is evolving.
Why this matters for insurers
These insights are often framed as a communication challenge, with a focus on simplifying language or improving how products are explained. While clarity helps, the underlying tension runs deeper.
The current model relies heavily on members perceiving long-term value, often without regularly experiencing it in a tangible way. As financial pressure increases, that gap becomes harder to sustain.

There is a growing need to make value more visible and more immediate. That includes helping members navigate the healthcare system, supporting prevention and early intervention, and creating experiences that feel relevant to their day-to-day lives.
Differentiation also becomes more important in this context. When members are actively considering switching, the funds that stand out will be those offering something that feels meaningfully different, whether through care models, partnerships, or overall experience.
The system dynamic at play
What this research highlights is a broader system dynamic that continues to shape private healthcare. Members are questioning value, insurers are managing rising costs, providers are operating with significant pricing discretion, and government intervention remains reactive.
Each part of the system influences the others, often reinforcing existing pressures. Over time, that dynamic can lead to increasing friction for members, particularly when costs rise without a corresponding improvement in experience.

Changing that dynamic requires more than incremental adjustments. It calls for a more active role from insurers in shaping how care is accessed, delivered, and experienced.
A window that won’t stay open
At the moment, insurers are supported by a customer base that continues to prioritise private health insurance, even when there are frustrations. That creates a degree of stability, but it also masks underlying vulnerability.
As cost pressures persist and expectations continue to evolve, behaviour is likely to shift more noticeably. Members will look for clearer value, and they will be more willing to act if they cannot find it.
The funds that respond early, by simplifying experiences, strengthening their propositions, and making value more tangible, will be better placed to shape what comes next. Others may find themselves reacting to changes that are already underway.

Download a free copy of our PHI Innovation Report
It’s Australia’s definitive benchmark of private health insurance innovation, ranking the nation’s leading funds and revealing the strategies reshaping affordability, prevention and digital care.
Exclusively free for Innovation Insiders

